×

Loading...
Ad by
  • 予人玫瑰,手有余香:加拿大新天地工作移民诚聘求职顾问&行业导师!
Ad by
  • 予人玫瑰,手有余香:加拿大新天地工作移民诚聘求职顾问&行业导师!

here is parts of the story he told me: (again, sorry no chinese input)

本文发表在 rolia.net 枫下论坛about 20 years ago, he came back to Canada and he was told his PR card had expired

He was shock, and he questioned the officer, what do you mean my permanent residence card has expired, it's called "permanent". (I think he has a point here)
and then he told them: my wife is a Canadian, and we live in Canada, we have a house in XXX, and my kid goes to Canada school. I work in a Canada company, and here is my Canadian driver license. blab blab blab, Are you not letting me in only because this piece of card is expired?

after all the complaints, those officers began to apologize and asked him to fill out a simple form, and let him enter Canada.

He later tried to fill out the forms to renew the card, and he realized the form was way too complicated and too many fields he did not know how to answer. So he decided, fxxk it, I am not going to renew it.

Because he sees his Germany passport more valuable, he didn't apply Canadian citizenship. Every time he crossed the border, he simply shows the border officer his expired card, and he is asked to fill out a form, spends 20 minutes in the office and explains the story, and he will be allowed to enter. My coworker is happy to do than filling out the renewal form. He says it's a principle thing. He refuses to renew it.


This whole story makes me feel he is right. There is no reason for people like us who lives and works in Canada to renew. The only reason to renew a PR card is because someone applies it but does not live in here. This thing, the government should figure out on their own. For example, when a PR enters Canada, scans the card so it has a record; when he/she leaves, scan the card again, so it knows this person is not living in Canada. Why the heck the government asks us to fill out so many stupid forms if we live and work here and pay all the taxes?

I think it's an interesting story and I just want to share更多精彩文章及讨论,请光临枫下论坛 rolia.net
Report

Replies, comments and Discussions:

  • 枫下家园 / 护照签证 / 要RENEW枫叶卡,过去5年里多次去美国玩,护照上只有去美国的时间章,却没有回到加拿大的日期章。 怎么才知道呢谢谢
    • 很简单。没有加拿大的章,但加拿大边境局有记录。给边境局 BORDER SERVICES打个电话,他们会给你寄出入境记录,免费的。
      • 谢谢!!刚打了电话,要30天才能收到记录。 可是5月中旬就必须要到美国一趟。怎么办呀? 网上说的 加急办理RENEW 是真的可以加急吗?
        • 再打电话问,可否加急?
          • 谢谢。刚打了电话,没有办法加急。
            • 对不起。想开些吧。:)
              • 还好,有下面的办法可以解决。 谢谢了
        • May I have the phone#? what personal information the Border services need to provide the report? thanks a lot!
    • just saying, I was told an interesting story by a Germany coworker: PR card does not need to renew. His has expired over 20 years, and he has crossed the border over 30 times with it. Sorry no chinese input in the office.
      • 谢谢。可是不敢冒险呀
      • 你 的同事有一部分是对的。如果1) 你 在加拿大生活时间够长 2)回到加拿大是坐私人轿车的话。 是可以入关的。--刚与一个OFFICER通话。 谢谢你的帮助
        • 够长的定义是啥?多长算够长? 坐别人的私人轿车可以,还是必须得自己开的私人轿车才行?
          • 忘了问。但是自己的车总是不会错的。
            • 那多长才算够长呢?
              • 哈,我没问,他就问我住了多长。超过5年了,SO
                • 知道啦。你可以,那么5年就算够长的了。
        • here is parts of the story he told me: (again, sorry no chinese input)
          本文发表在 rolia.net 枫下论坛about 20 years ago, he came back to Canada and he was told his PR card had expired

          He was shock, and he questioned the officer, what do you mean my permanent residence card has expired, it's called "permanent". (I think he has a point here)
          and then he told them: my wife is a Canadian, and we live in Canada, we have a house in XXX, and my kid goes to Canada school. I work in a Canada company, and here is my Canadian driver license. blab blab blab, Are you not letting me in only because this piece of card is expired?

          after all the complaints, those officers began to apologize and asked him to fill out a simple form, and let him enter Canada.

          He later tried to fill out the forms to renew the card, and he realized the form was way too complicated and too many fields he did not know how to answer. So he decided, fxxk it, I am not going to renew it.

          Because he sees his Germany passport more valuable, he didn't apply Canadian citizenship. Every time he crossed the border, he simply shows the border officer his expired card, and he is asked to fill out a form, spends 20 minutes in the office and explains the story, and he will be allowed to enter. My coworker is happy to do than filling out the renewal form. He says it's a principle thing. He refuses to renew it.


          This whole story makes me feel he is right. There is no reason for people like us who lives and works in Canada to renew. The only reason to renew a PR card is because someone applies it but does not live in here. This thing, the government should figure out on their own. For example, when a PR enters Canada, scans the card so it has a record; when he/she leaves, scan the card again, so it knows this person is not living in Canada. Why the heck the government asks us to fill out so many stupid forms if we live and work here and pay all the taxes?

          I think it's an interesting story and I just want to share更多精彩文章及讨论,请光临枫下论坛 rolia.net
          • Yes, he is absolutely right! I will learn from your guys . I just ASK but did not FIGHT for my right . Thank you for sharing. HAPPY CHINESE NEW YEAR!
            • 我觉得,FIGHT FOR YOUR RIGHTS没错。不过不需要啥都要去FIGHT 一下吧?边境局早就有明确指示,移民部也有明确指示,告诉我们如何如何做。如果你不这么临时抱佛脚,就不会有今天这个问题,是不是?:)按照规定来办,省力气,省精力。
              • 你批评的对。 我还是在申请的。 只不过想有一个BACK UP PLAN. 一直在检查护照有没有过期,忘了检查PR CARD 的 。
                • 我自己有一个LIST,所有卡的EXPIRE 日期都有。不会忘记。:)
                  • 学习了。 :-)
          • would you mind ask your co-worker , he comes back Canada by car or by plane every time? The office told me I can come back Canada only by LAND if I hold the expired card. .Thanks.
            • 飞机是绝对不行的。明文规定的。如果那个同事飞机也可以,我要打电话去抗议边境局对人不一致。LOL.
              • LOL. 好了,有一大堆表要填呢。祝你马年快乐。祝我自己马年不再拖拖拉拉的了。今日事今日毕。
                • 好吧。LOL。
            • sure, he is currently away on a meeting, I will ask him when he is back.
            • ok, I asked. He can only travel by land. He cannot have international flight from Canada, so he has to travel to States and fly there using his Germany passport. that makes sense
              • 才看到。谢谢了
      • 问题是他是德国护照,德国护照进入加拿大需要签证么?
        • 不需要。德国和加拿大双方都免签。加拿大护照去德国,可以免签至少三个月。
          • 请问skatingcat 你的list都包括哪些?PR,驾照,健康卡?
            • 还有护照呀。
          • 对啊,所以他没有枫叶卡也可以回加拿大是很正常的事情。但是天朝的护照就……难说了。